Tax lien, tax deed, or tax foreclosure? How the three systems compare
"Tax sale" means three different things in the states we cover. Florida first sells a tax certificate, a lien that earns interest, and only later auctions the property. California's tax collector sells the property itself after years of default. Michigan forecloses first, so the county treasurer already owns what it auctions. What you buy, what you can earn, how you bid and how long the process takes all follow from that difference.
By Tax Sale Intel research desk · Reviewed against the statutes cited below · Methodology
California, Florida and Michigan at a glance
- What is sold
- Florida: a tax certificate (lien), and later the property at a tax deed sale. California: the property. Michigan: property the county already owns after foreclosure
- Who runs the sale
- Florida: the Tax Collector (certificates) and the Clerk of Court (deeds). California: the Treasurer-Tax Collector, with board of supervisors approval. Michigan: the foreclosing governmental unit, usually the county treasurer
- Florida certificate bidding
- Lowest interest rate wins, bid down from an 18% maximum in quarter-point steps
- California minimum price
- At least the total amount needed to redeem, plus costs
- Michigan minimum bid
- All delinquent taxes, interest, penalties and fees, and may include foreclosure and sale costs
- When the property can be sold
- Florida: tax deed application 2 years after April 1 of the certificate year. California: after 5 years of default (3 for nonresidential commercial). Michigan: after title vests on March 31, at auctions from July to early November
- If nobody bids
- Florida: the parcel goes to the certificate holder, or to the lands available for taxes list if the holder does not pay. California: reoffered, possibly at a lower minimum. Michigan: a final sale with no minimum bid, then transfer to the local unit
- Former owner buying back
- California and Michigan: not below the minimum price or minimum bid
On this page
- Three different things called a tax sale
- Florida, step one: bidding on interest
- Florida, step two: the tax deed sale
- California: the county sells the property
- Michigan: foreclosure first, auction second
- How bidding differs
- How long each process takes
- Interest or ownership
- Questions to ask before you bid in any state
Three different things called a tax sale
In Florida, the first sale after taxes go unpaid is not a property sale. The Tax Collector sells a tax certificate: the buyer pays the delinquent taxes and holds a lien that earns interest until the owner pays. Florida law makes property taxes a first lien, superior to all other liens, from January 1 of the year they are levied (Fla. Stat. 197.122). The property is sold only if a holder later forces a Clerk's tax deed sale.
California has no lien sale: unpaid taxes default at 12:01 a.m. on July 1 (Rev. & Tax. Code 3436), and years later the Treasurer-Tax Collector auctions the property. In Michigan the county treasurer takes title through a court foreclosure before any auction, so the buyer purchases from a government owner.
Florida, step one: bidding on interest
Florida tax collectors must advertise once a week for three weeks and sell certificates on all real property with delinquent taxes on or before June 1, or the 60th day after delinquency if that is later (Fla. Stat. 197.402). Bidders do not compete on price. The certificate goes to the bidder who will pay the taxes, interest, costs and charges and accept the lowest interest rate, bid in quarter-point steps (Fla. Stat. 197.432). The maximum is 18% a year (Fla. Stat. 197.172). Certificates nobody buys are struck to the county at the maximum rate.
Buyers pay within 48 hours after the tax collector's notice that certificates are ready, and the tax collector's 5% commission is built into the face value (Fla. Stat. 197.432).
The return is interest, not property. When the owner redeems, the holder receives the face amount plus interest. If the interest earned is under 5% of the face amount, a 5% minimum applies, except on certificates bid down to zero percent (Fla. Stat. 197.472). A holder may not contact the owner to encourage or demand payment until two years after April 1 of the year the certificate was issued (Fla. Stat. 197.432), and a certificate expires seven years after issue if no tax deed application or other proceeding is on record (Fla. Stat. 197.482).
Florida, step two: the tax deed sale
Two years after April 1 of the year of issue, the holder may apply for a tax deed, paying a $75 application fee (plus any online service cost), all other outstanding certificates, any omitted, delinquent and current taxes, and the costs of the sale. Counties must apply on certificates they hold for property valued at $5,000 or more (Fla. Stat. 197.502).
The Clerk of Court then auctions the property. The certificate holder's own bid, which opens the sale, is the redemption amount plus the applicant's costs and interest at 1.5% a month. For homestead property it also includes one-half of the assessed value. Anyone, including the certificate holder, can bid higher. The high bidder posts a nonrefundable deposit of 5% of the bid or $200, whichever is greater, and must pay in full within 24 hours, excluding weekends and legal holidays (Fla. Stat. 197.542). If nobody bids higher, the property is struck off to the certificate holder, who must pay any remaining amounts within 30 days.
California: the county sells the property
After five years of default, or three years for nonresidential commercial property unless the county has chosen five, the tax collector has the power to sell. The statute says any person may buy, regardless of any prior lien on, claim to, or interest in the property (Rev. & Tax. Code 3691). The tax collector must attempt a sale within four years after the property becomes subject to sale and, if there are no acceptable bids, try again at intervals of no more than six years (Rev. & Tax. Code 3692). Each sale needs board of supervisors approval (Rev. & Tax. Code 3694).
Bidding starts from a minimum price of at least the total amount needed to redeem (defaulted taxes, penalties, costs and a redemption fee), plus sale costs and any unpaid state property tax postponement loan. If a parcel drew no acceptable bid at an earlier sale, the tax collector may, with board approval, reoffer it at a lower minimum. The current owner may not buy the property, directly or indirectly, below the full minimum (Rev. & Tax. Code 3698.5). The tax collector executes the deed after receiving the full purchase price (Rev. & Tax. Code 3708).
Los Angeles County advertises each auction in local newspapers for three consecutive weeks, starting at least 21 days ahead. San Bernardino County's online sale uses proxy bidding and extends bidding by two minutes whenever a new leader emerges in the final two minutes.
Michigan: foreclosure first, auction second
Property delinquent for 12 months or more is forfeited to the county treasurer on March 1, with a $175 fee added (MCL 211.78g). After a court judgment, fee simple title vests in the foreclosing governmental unit if the taxes are not paid by the March 31 after the judgment, or within 21 days in a contested case (MCL 211.78k).
Before any public auction, the state, then the city, village or township, then the county and a county land bank may buy the property. They must act by the first Tuesday in July. The state pays the greater of the minimum bid and fair market value. Local governments and land banks pay the minimum bid, or that greater amount if a former owner has filed a claim for remaining proceeds (MCL 211.78m).
Auctions run from the third Tuesday in July to the first Tuesday in November and may be held online. The minimum bid must include all delinquent taxes, interest, penalties and fees and may add the government's foreclosure and auction expenses. A county holding several sales can run a final sale, at least 28 days after the previous one, with no minimum bid, though a former interest holder must still pay the full minimum. Payment is due at the close of the day's bidding or within 21 days, and the deed follows within 14 days of payment. Property still unsold transfers to the city, village or township by December 30 unless it objects (MCL 211.78m).
Wayne County auctions in September and October; parcels unsold in September return in October at a fixed minimum bid that includes the treasurer's foreclosure and auction expenses.
How bidding differs
Only Florida's certificate sale has bidders competing downward, on interest rate, with the price fixed at the taxes owed. Every property sale bids upward from a floor, and the floors differ: Florida's opening bid repays the certificate holder with 1.5% a month plus costs, California's minimum covers everything needed to redeem plus sale costs, and Michigan's covers the delinquency plus, optionally, the treasurer's costs, with no minimum at all at a season's final sale.
How long each process takes
Florida sells a lien within months of delinquency, allows a tax deed application two years after April 1 of the certificate year, and voids the certificate after seven years if nobody applies. California waits five years of default, or three for some commercial property, and then may take up to four more years to offer the parcel. Michigan forfeits property after 12 months of delinquency, takes title the following March 31 after a judgment, and must finish its auctions by the first Tuesday in November of that year.
Interest or ownership
A Florida certificate holder is closer to a lender: the return is the bid rate, capped at 18%, and ends when the owner redeems. The holder gets the property only through a tax deed sale, by outbidding everyone or by drawing no higher bid. A California or Michigan buyer earns no interest and takes on the property, its condition and whatever survives the sale, so the research is about the property rather than the lien. This guide explains mechanics only and is not legal or investment advice.
Questions to ask before you bid in any state
These questions apply in every state.
- Am I buying a lien, a property from a tax collector, or a property the county already owns?
- Who runs this sale, and where are its written terms for this specific auction?
- How is the minimum or opening bid built, and has the parcel been offered before at a higher minimum?
- Can the owner still redeem, and until when? Our redemption guide compares the cutoffs.
- What deposit, payment method and payment deadline apply, and what happens if I miss it?
- What liens, easements and restrictions survive the sale in this state?
California, Florida and Michigan county research
- Miami-Dade CountyClerk tax deed calendar, current listings, and past results
- Los Angeles CountyAuction calendar, current lists, and past auction records
- San Bernardino CountySale schedule, parcel records, and auction history
- Wayne County (Detroit)Auction catalog and past auction records
Terms used in this guide
Sources
- Florida Statutes 197.122 (lien of taxes)
- Florida Statutes 197.172 (interest rate; 18% maximum)
- Florida Statutes 197.402 (advertisement and certificate sale deadline)
- Florida Statutes 197.432 (sale of tax certificates)
- Florida Statutes 197.472 (redemption of tax certificates)
- Florida Statutes 197.482 (expiration of tax certificates)
- Florida Statutes 197.502 (tax deed application)
- Florida Statutes 197.542 (sale at public auction)
- Revenue and Taxation Code 3436 (default on July 1)
- Revenue and Taxation Code 3691 (power to sell)
- Revenue and Taxation Code 3692 (when sales must be attempted)
- Revenue and Taxation Code 3694 (board of supervisors approval)
- Revenue and Taxation Code 3698.5 (minimum price)
- Revenue and Taxation Code 3708 (deed to purchaser)
- Los Angeles County Treasurer and Tax Collector: auction FAQ
- San Bernardino County tax sale FAQ
- MCL 211.78g (forfeiture)
- MCL 211.78k (foreclosure judgment and title vesting)
- MCL 211.78m (right of first refusal, auctions, minimum bid)
- Wayne County Treasurer: claims and auctions
- Wayne County Treasurer's auction FAQ
General information, not legal advice. Statutes change and each county publishes its own sale terms. Confirm deadlines with the county and get qualified advice for a specific purchase.