Redemption rights and what survives a tax sale: California, Florida and Michigan compared

Redemption is the owner's right to pay what is owed and keep the property. California, Florida and Michigan each end that right at a different point: before the auction starts, when the tax deed issues, or on a fixed March 31 months before any auction. Each state also lets a different set of easements, liens and restrictions survive the sale. Both questions decide what a buyer actually gets.

By Tax Sale Intel research desk · Reviewed against the statutes cited below · Methodology

California, Florida and Michigan at a glance

California: redemption ends
Close of business on the last business day before the tax sale begins
Florida: redemption ends
When the tax deed is issued, unless full payment for the deed has already reached the Clerk
Michigan: redemption ends
March 31 after the foreclosure judgment, or 21 days after judgment in a contested case
Redemption after bidding closes
California: no. Florida: until the winning bidder's full payment reaches the Clerk. Michigan: no, title vested before the auction
California: what survives
Easements, restrictions of record, separately held water rights, liens of non-consenting taxing agencies, some special assessments and bonds, some IRS liens
Florida: what survives
Unpaid recorded liens of a city, county, special district or community development district; certain easements; use restrictions
Michigan: what survives
Visible or recorded easements and rights-of-way, private deed restrictions, future special assessment installments, certain oil and gas and environmental interests
Time limits to challenge
California: petition within 1 year of the deed. Florida: 4 years after the buyer takes possession. Michigan: 2 years after the judgment takes effect

Three systems, three meanings of redemption

Where redemption sits depends on what is being sold. California sells the property itself at a tax collector's auction. Florida first sells a tax certificate, a lien that earns interest, and only later auctions the property through the Clerk of Court. Michigan forecloses first: a court gives title to the county treasurer, and the treasurer auctions property later.

So a California owner redeems to stop an auction, a Florida owner to pay off a certificate holder, and a Michigan owner to stop a foreclosure judgment from taking effect.

California: redemption ends before the auction

After five years of tax default, or three years for nonresidential commercial property unless the county has chosen five, the tax collector gains the power to sell (Rev. & Tax. Code 3691). The owner can redeem until the close of business on the last business day before the sale begins. The start of the sale counts as the sale date even if bidding on a parcel ends later, and a mailed payment must arrive by that deadline (Rev. & Tax. Code 3707).

Once the deadline passes, anyone with record title loses all rights in the property. The right revives only in two cases: if the property does not sell, or if the county allowed a credit sale and the buyer did not pay in full on time.

Florida: redemption runs until the deed issues

A Florida tax certificate can be redeemed at any time after it is issued and before a tax deed is issued, unless full payment for the deed, including documentary stamps and recording fees, has already reached the Clerk. The person redeeming pays the face amount plus interest, costs and charges. If the interest earned is under 5% of the face amount, a 5% minimum applies, except on certificates bid down to zero percent. The tax collector charges $6.25 per certificate redeemed (Fla. Stat. 197.472).

This leaves a short gap after the auction. A Florida winning bidder must pay in full within 24 hours, excluding weekends and legal holidays (Fla. Stat. 197.542). Until that payment reaches the Clerk, the owner can still redeem.

Michigan: the March 31 deadline comes before any auction

Michigan taxes still unpaid on March 1 of the year after they were levied are returned as delinquent (MCL 211.78a). A year later, on March 1, property delinquent for 12 months or more is forfeited to the county treasurer, who adds a $175 fee and records a certificate of forfeiture within 45 days. Forfeiture does not transfer title: the certificate states that title will vest in the foreclosing governmental unit only if the property is not redeemed by the March 31 after a foreclosure judgment. Redeeming now costs additional noncompounded interest of 1/2% a month (MCL 211.78g).

In an uncontested case the court enters its foreclosure judgment by March 30, effective March 31. All redemption rights expire that March 31, or 21 days after judgment in a contested case. Title then vests absolutely in the foreclosing governmental unit, which gets possession on April 1. After that date the judgment cannot be modified, stayed or held invalid except through an appeal under the statute (MCL 211.78k). A person other than the owner who redeems, such as a mortgage lender, gets a lien for the amount paid that must be recorded within 30 days (MCL 211.78g).

What survives a California tax deed

A California tax deed conveys title free of all earlier encumbrances, with listed exceptions (Rev. & Tax. Code 3712). The ones buyers meet most often are:

  • Easements of any kind, water rights held separately from the land, and recorded restrictions.
  • Installments of taxes and special assessments that come due after the sale.
  • Liens of a taxing agency that did not consent to the sale, and special assessments not included in the redemption amount.
  • Unpaid 1915 Act improvement bond assessments and Mello-Roos special taxes not satisfied from the sale proceeds.
  • Unaccepted recorded offers to dedicate the land for public use, and recorded options of a taxing agency to buy it for public use.
  • Federal IRS liens that federal law does not discharge.

What survives a Florida tax deed

Florida's rule has the same shape: except as Chapter 197 provides, no right, interest, restriction or covenant survives a tax deed. The main exception is any recorded lien of a city, county, special district or community development district that is not paid when the sale proceeds are disbursed (Fla. Stat. 197.552).

Some easements also survive: those for conservation, utilities and other public services, support of improvements, drainage, and access to other land. Each must be recorded before the tax deed or shown by visible use such as poles, a waterway or a road (Fla. Stat. 197.572). Usual use restrictions survive too, including limits on building type and covenants against nuisances, and so does a condominium or homeowners association's lien for assessments that come due after the deed. Covenants that create other debts or require the owner to spend money generally do not survive, and rights of reverter and reentry are destroyed (Fla. Stat. 197.573). The Miami-Dade Clerk warns that it makes no representation about liens or encumbrances that may survive.

What survives a Michigan tax foreclosure

A Michigan foreclosure judgment extinguishes all liens, including unpaid taxes and special assessments, except future special assessment installments and liens recorded by the state or the foreclosing unit under the state's environmental protection act. It also extinguishes all recorded and unrecorded interests, except visible or recorded easements and rights-of-way, private deed restrictions, recorded oil and gas lessee interests, certain preserved oil and gas interests, interests assessed as personal property, and environmental restrictions (MCL 211.78k).

Because the treasurer already holds title, the auction buyer gets a deed from the treasurer. Wayne County tells buyers that successful bidders receive a quit claim deed, that properties are sold as is and where is with no warranties, and that buyers should research condition, special assessments, environmental issues and demolition status before the auction.

How long a sale can be challenged

Each state limits how long a former owner can attack the sale. In California, a court case over an invalid or irregular sale requires a petition to the board of supervisors within one year of the deed's execution, then a lawsuit within one year of the board's decision (Rev. & Tax. Code 3725). The board can also rescind a sale that should not have happened, unless the property has passed to a bona fide purchaser or become subject to a bona fide encumbrance for value (Rev. & Tax. Code 3731).

In Florida, once the deed holder takes actual possession, a former owner has 4 years to sue to recover possession (Fla. Stat. 95.191), and the deed is prima facie evidence that the proceedings were regular (Fla. Stat. 197.552). In Michigan, holders of extinguished interests cannot sue more than 2 years after the judgment takes effect, and claims to sale proceeds must go through the remaining proceeds process (MCL 211.78l).

What differs and why it matters

For owners, the question is how late is too late: the business day before a California sale opens, the moment a Florida buyer's payment lands, or a fixed Michigan March 31 before any auction. For bidders, the question is what comes with the deed. Florida keeps unpaid recorded local government liens, California keeps several kinds of special assessment, bond and non-consenting agency liens, and Michigan's judgment keeps only future special assessment installments and certain environmental liens. This is general information, not legal advice.

  • Recheck the parcel status on the day bidding opens; redeemed parcels drop out.
  • Search city and county records for code, utility and special assessment liens.
  • Read the recorded easements and restrictions in the chain of title.
  • Ask a title company how it treats tax deeds in that state before relying on one.

California, Florida and Michigan county research

Terms used in this guide

Sources

General information, not legal advice. Statutes change and each county publishes its own sale terms. Confirm deadlines with the county and get qualified advice for a specific purchase.