Surplus proceeds after a tax sale: California, Florida and Michigan compared
When a tax sale brings in more than the taxes, interest and costs owed, the extra is held for the people who had an interest in the property. California, Florida and Michigan all let lienholders and former owners claim it, but each state starts the clock at a different event, sends claims to a different decision-maker, and closes the window on a different day. Missing that day can mean losing the money.
By Tax Sale Intel research desk · Reviewed against the statutes cited below · Methodology
California, Florida and Michigan at a glance
- California: who can claim
- Lienholders of record first, then anyone who held record title before the tax deed was recorded
- California: deadline
- Claim filed or postmarked within 1 year after the tax deed is recorded
- Florida: who can claim
- Government lienholders first, then mortgagees, lienholders and titleholders who were entitled to notice of the sale
- Florida: deadline
- Notarized claim within 120 days of the Clerk's mailed surplus notice
- Michigan: who can claim
- Anyone with a legal interest in the property just before the foreclosure judgment took effect
- Michigan: deadlines
- Notarized notice of intent by the July 1 after foreclosure, then a court motion between February 1 and May 15 after the sale
- Who decides
- California: board of supervisors. Florida: the Clerk, or a court if claims conflict. Michigan: the circuit court
- Unclaimed money
- California: may move to the county general fund. Florida: presumed the titleholder's and handled as unclaimed property. Michigan: the statute is the only route to payment
On this page
What surplus is, and why states return it
Every tax sale has a floor: the delinquent taxes, interest, penalties and costs of the sale. Bidding often goes higher. California calls the difference excess proceeds, Florida calls it surplus, and Michigan calls it remaining proceeds. In each state the government keeps what it is owed and holds the rest for the people who had an interest in the property.
In 2023 the U.S. Supreme Court decided Tyler v. Hennepin County. A Minnesota county had sold a condominium for $40,000 to collect a tax debt of about $15,000, including interest and penalties, and kept the $25,000 difference. The Court held unanimously that the owner plausibly alleged an unconstitutional taking, and noted that most states already require excess value to be returned to the taxpayer. All three states covered here require a written claim. None pays automatically.
California: excess proceeds
After a California tax sale, the county first takes a $1.50 state fee per parcel, its advertising costs, and the other amounts the code lists. Anything left stays in the county's delinquent tax sale trust fund on account of the parties of interest (Rev. & Tax. Code 4672 to 4674).
If the excess is more than $150, the county must mail notice of the right to claim to the last known address of each party of interest no later than 90 days after the sale. If an address cannot be found, it publishes notice in a local newspaper once a week for three weeks, unless publishing would cost as much as the excess itself (Rev. & Tax. Code 4676).
A claim must be filed, or postmarked, within one year after the tax collector's deed is recorded. The clock starts at recording, not at the auction. San Bernardino County, for example, tells buyers that tax deeds are recorded within 90 days after the close of the sale. No sooner than one year after recording, the board of supervisors orders payment in this order: lienholders of record first, in their order of priority, then anyone who held record title before the tax deed was recorded (Rev. & Tax. Code 4675).
Heirs of a deceased titleholder can support a claim with an affidavit under Probate Code section 13100 and following. A claimant who disagrees with the county's decision has 90 days to seek review. Money nobody claims can be transferred to the county general fund after the county deducts its unrecovered costs (Rev. & Tax. Code 4674 and 4675).
Florida: surplus held by the Clerk
In Florida, the Clerk of Court first repays the tax certificate holder whose application forced the sale, with interest at 1.5% a month. Money above that statutory bid is surplus. If the property was homestead and the opening bid included one-half of its assessed value, that amount is treated as surplus too (Fla. Stat. 197.582).
The Clerk pays recorded government liens first. The balance is held for the people who were entitled to notice of the sale, such as titleholders, mortgagees and lienholders. The Clerk mails each a notice, and each has 120 days from the date of that notice to file a notarized claim. A mailed claim counts as filed on its postmark date.
Within 90 days after the claim period ends, the Clerk either pays claims by priority or, if claims conflict, files an interpleader action and lets the circuit court decide. Anyone other than the property owner who misses the 120 days is barred. If no one files a claim at all, the law conclusively presumes the titleholder of record is entitled to the money, and the Clerk processes it under Florida's unclaimed property law (Fla. Stat. 197.582).
Michigan: remaining proceeds after Rafaeli
Michigan's claim process is MCL 211.78t, added by 2020 PA 256 and effective December 22, 2020. The Legislature described it as codifying the right of former interest holders to remaining proceeds that the Michigan Supreme Court recognized in Rafaeli, LLC v Oakland County. It covers property sold or transferred after July 17, 2020. For earlier sales, the statute allows claims only if the Michigan Supreme Court orders Rafaeli to apply retroactively, so anyone with an older foreclosure should get legal advice.
Michigan's first deadline falls before the auction. By the July 1 after the foreclosure takes effect, a claimant must give the foreclosing governmental unit, usually the county treasurer, a notarized notice of intent on the Department of Treasury form, by certified mail or acknowledged personal delivery. Wayne County's treasurer set July 1, 2026 as the deadline for properties foreclosed in March 2026.
By the January 31 after the sale, the treasurer mails each claimant the sale result. Claimants then file a motion in the same circuit court case that entered the foreclosure, between February 1 and May 15. The court holds a hearing, decides each claimant's priority and value, and the treasurer pays within 21 days of the order (MCL 211.78t).
Remaining proceeds are what is left after the minimum bid, other costs of forfeiting, foreclosing, selling, maintaining, repairing and remediating the property, and a 5% sale commission. The statute calls itself the exclusive way to claim, and the right cannot be transferred except by will or inheritance.
What differs and why it matters
The three states start the clock at different events. California counts from the recording of the tax deed, Florida from the Clerk's mailed notice, and Michigan from the date the foreclosure takes effect, which comes months before any auction. A Michigan owner who waits to see whether a property sells for more than the debt has already missed the July 1 notice.
Decision-makers differ too. California's board of supervisors orders payment, Florida's Clerk pays or hands conflicts to a judge, and in Michigan a judge decides from the start.
So do deductions. Michigan takes a 5% commission plus its costs, Florida pays the Clerk's service charges and mailing costs from the surplus, and California deducts the cost of finding and notifying claimants.
Recovery services and assignments
Large surpluses attract companies that offer to file the claim for a share of the money. Owners can usually file themselves: Florida's Clerk must mail a claim form with its surplus notice, and Michigan's Treasury form must be posted online. California adds specific protections: after a sale, the right to claim can be assigned only by a dated, written agreement that says so explicitly, after both sides disclose what they know about its value. Anyone filing on a claimant's behalf must show that the claimant was told the amount and source of the excess and their right to file directly with the county at no cost (Rev. & Tax. Code 4675). In Michigan, the right cannot be sold at all.
What this means for bidders
Surplus rules do not change what a winning bidder pays, but two details matter. In Florida, a tax deed buyer who pays off government liens that could have been paid from the surplus can file a timely claim and be reimbursed in the same priority as the original lienholder (Fla. Stat. 197.582). In Michigan, if a claimant bought the property back at auction or still holds an interest, the court must apply the proceeds to unpaid obligations owed to tenants and to certain unpaid local ordinance fines (MCL 211.78t).
A large gap between the opening and winning bids signals that a surplus claim may follow, not that anyone will collect it.
Checklist for former owners and lienholders
General information, not legal advice. Confirm every date with the county office that holds the money.
- Identify the office: the county treasurer-tax collector in California, the Clerk of Court in Florida, the foreclosing county treasurer in Michigan.
- Write down the date that starts your clock: deed recording, the Clerk's notice date, or the foreclosure effective date.
- Gather proof of your interest: the recorded deed, mortgage, or lien and the amount still owed.
- Use the official claim form and send it by a method that proves the filing date.
- Read any recovery agreement closely before signing, and compare its fee with filing yourself.
California, Florida and Michigan county research
- Los Angeles CountyAuction calendar, current lists, and past auction records
- San Bernardino CountySale schedule, parcel records, and auction history
- Miami-Dade CountyClerk tax deed calendar, current listings, and past results
- Wayne County (Detroit)Auction catalog and past auction records
Terms used in this guide
Sources
- Revenue and Taxation Code 4672 (state fee from sale proceeds)
- Revenue and Taxation Code 4674 (excess held for parties of interest)
- Revenue and Taxation Code 4675 (excess proceeds claims)
- Revenue and Taxation Code 4676 (notice of right to claim)
- San Bernardino County tax sale FAQ
- Florida Statutes 197.582 (disbursement of proceeds of sale)
- MCL 211.78t (claims for remaining proceeds)
- Wayne County Treasurer: claims and auctions
- Tyler v. Hennepin County, 598 U.S. 631 (2023)
General information, not legal advice. Statutes change and each county publishes its own sale terms. Confirm deadlines with the county and get qualified advice for a specific purchase.